Sicilian Stuffed Meat Roll

Scusami! This is not your average meatloaf

Updated 9/26/2023

This recipe was inspired by my friend Joan, who is a fantastic cook with an open mind.  She worked in the Detroit-Windsor auto sector along with coworkers from a variety of ethnic groups and spoke fondly of how they would exchange recipes.

When Joan offered to make us dinner one day, she served what she called Italian Stuffed Meatloaf, a recipe she got from an Italian co-worker. Everybody thought it was amazing and I just loved how she had elevated the mundane meatloaf to the epicurean realm.

Italian influences on American Cuisine

Starting in the late 1800s, waves of Italian immigrants were drawn to major North American cities. Most came from southern Italy and the island of Sicily, in search for a better life. They brought their rich cultural heritage, traditions, and culinary practices with them. Generations of Italian Americans have adapted their traditional recipes to American ingredients and tastes into a distinct Italian-American cuisine. Many of these dishes have become classics that you’ll find at your local pizzeria or an old- school ristorante in Little Italy.

Today, the largest Little Italy in the Detroit area is on the Canadian side of the border in Windsor, Ontario. You’ll find some top-rated Italian restaurants and shops along Via Italia. This vibrant neighbourhood, concentrated along Erie Street in downtown Windsor, is popular with locals and visitors.

If you’re lucky, you’ll find Involtini Siciliani or Braciole on the menu. These traditional Sicilian meat roll dishes are similar in concept to our home made meat roll recipe. It’s comfort food with an old world twist. Sicilian stuffed meatroll is a crowd pleaser with company and a family treat any night of the week.

Meat roll cooking tips

After you’ve prepped all the ingredients, start by cracking an egg into a large mixing bowl. Stir in the seasonings, onion, garlic and a portion of the tomato sauce until all are well blended. You can use regular tomato sauce, crushed tomatoes, passata, or marinara. A good quality, store-bought marinara really enhances this recipe. Next, mix in the fresh lean ground beef and breadcrumbs until all are well blended.

You’ll then pour the meat mixture onto a plastic cling wrap and shape into a rectangle about ½-inch thick. Spread the meat slices, then the cheese, over the flattened meat mixture. Just stay about an inch away from the edges. Start to roll it up with the aid of the plastic wrap to like a jelly roll. Tuck in the edges to prevent the melted cheese from leaking out during cooking. Form it into the shape of a loaf and place it on a broiler pan. You’ll want to add some water to the bottom of the pan to prevent the dripping grease from scorching.

You can make your own variation of the stuffing, using other Italian cheeses like Parmesan, Pecorino, and adding spinach or basil leaves. Refrigerate leftover meat roll and serve the next day as a cold appetizer as you would a pâté or terrine. 

Did you make this recipe?
Add your comment and rating below
Share your photos on Instagram
@the_worldonaplatter

Side dish suggestions

• Italian Bean Salad
• Garlic Mashed Potatoes
• Roasted Potatoes with Mirepoix
• Butter-Braised Brussels Sprouts